Skip to content
Niagara river beach view

About

Toxics Management Plan

Hydroelectric generating stations on the Niagara River gorge below the Lewiston-Queenston Bridge

Over the past 150 years, human activities have impacted the Niagara River ecosystem.

Early pollution problems were caused by sewage, bacteria, oil and other industrial chemicals. Actions such as regulatory changes restricting pollution discharges, improvements to wastewater treatment, and cleanup of contaminated sites have contributed to addressing pollution problems and reducing toxic substances in the river.

Legacy Contamination & the NRTMP

In 1981, the International Joint Commission completed a Special Report on Pollution in the Niagara River that indicated the Niagara River was a Problem Area where specific water quality objectives were not being achieved. The report called for a comprehensive study of the Niagara River system. Four environmental agencies, Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Ontario Ministry of the Environment, and Climate Change (MOECC), and New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) (collectively referred to as the ‘Four Parties’ and known at the time as the Niagara River Toxics Committee) conducted the study between 1981 and 1983, with a final report issued in 1984. The study revealed 261 different chemicals in the waters and sediment, with 89% of pollutants coming from sources on the U.S. side.

The Niagara River

In 1987, the Four Parties signed the Niagara River Declaration of Intent (DOI) to achieve significant reductions of chemical pollutants in the Niagara River. Together, the DOI and its work plan make up the Niagara River Toxics Management Plan (NRTMP) to reduce the amount of toxic chemicals discharged to the Niagara River through cooperative and independent agency activities. The NRTMP outlines a series of actions to be undertaken by the Four Parties, including:

  • Reduce toxic loadings from direct and indirect discharges;
  • Conduct research and monitoring to learn more about the water quality of the river;
  • Coordinate methodologies for identifying, quantifying and assessing toxic loadings; and
  • Communicate progress to the public.

After establishing the NRTMP, the Four Parties selected 18 “priority toxic” chemicals to target for reduction because they were present in the Niagara River/Lake Ontario ecosystem at unacceptably high levels. Of these 18 priority toxins, 10 were targeted to have a 50% reduction by 1996 because they were thought to have direct Niagara River sources.

18 Priority Toxic Chemicals

  • Chlordane
  • Mirex/Photomirex (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Dieldrin
  • Hexachlorobenzene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • DDT and metabolites
  • Toxaphene
  • Mercury (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Arsenic
  • Lead
  • PCBs (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Dioxin (2,3,7,8-TCDD) (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Octachlorostyrene
  • Tetrachloroethylene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Benz(a)anthracene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Benzo(a)pyrene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Benzo(b)fluoranthene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Benzo(k)fluoranthene (targeted for 50% reduction)
  • Chrysene/Triphenylene

*Targeted for 50% load reduction by 1996 from point and non-point Niagara River watershed sources using 1987 as a baseline.

Overall, the water quality of the Niagara River has improved significantly since the inception of the NRTMP. Based on a review of the most current trend information, the original goal of 50% reduction in the concentration of 10 of the 18 priority toxics either has been met or exceeded for all except PCBs, p,p’-DDE and the particulate phase PAHs. Despite this success, more work is underway to further reduce those compounds.

Aerial view of the Niagara River

International Cooperation

On December 3, 1996, the Four Parties signed a Letter of Support to re-affirm their commitment to the NRTMP. The revised objective (as stated in the Letter) is “to reduce toxic chemical concentrations in the [Niagara] River by reducing inputs from sources along the river, with the purpose of achieving ambient water quality that will protect human health, aquatic life, and wildlife, and while doing so, improve and protect water quality in Lake Ontario as well.”

The updated Plan of Action in the 1996 Letter of Support included:

  • measures for implementation of point source control;
  • trackdown and identification of new sources;
  • monitoring progress through the Upstream/Downstream program;
  • biomonitoring and the collection of sediment cores;
  • remediation and monitoring of progress at hazardous waste sites; and
  • relating remediation results to ambient conditions in the river.
Field staff wading in the Niagara River under a railway bridge to collect monitoring samples Field staff wading in the lower Niagara River at dusk, with the Lewiston-Queenston Bridge in the distance
Photos courtesy of the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (L. Richman)

Monitoring and Research

There are three components to monitoring identified in the 1996 Letter of Support: water quality, biomonitoring, and source trackdown.

Water Quality Monitoring

Through the Upstream-Downstream Program conducted by ECCC since 1986, ambient water quality information is collected at Fort Erie (head of the river) and at Niagara-on-the-Lake (mouth of the river) to determine which chemicals are originating upstream (i.e., Lake Erie and above) versus those being discharged from sources within the Niagara River watershed.

Due to the complex nature of this dynamic river system, identifying specific chemical concentrations is extremely challenging. Statistical results (90% confidence intervals) are compared against the strictest criteria amongst the Four Parties to determine relative progress over time.

Biomonitoring (fish and mussels)

Since 1983, the Ministry of Environment, Conservation, and Parks (MECP) (formerly MOECC) researchers have examined the concentrations of contaminants in caged mussels, and special sampling devices to measure a variety of toxic chemicals that can accumulate in living organisms in the Niagara River.

Young-of-the-year fish are collected by the NYSDEC and the MECP to monitor persistent organic contaminants in the Great Lakes Basin dating back into the 1970s. This information helps find localized problems, determine contaminant trends over time, and are useful to determine the success of cleanup efforts for hazardous waste sites.

Source Trackdown

One of the commitments in the 1996 Letter of Support by the Four Parties was to track-down new sources of pollution to control. Sediment investigations by ECCC (in Canada) and NYSDEC/USEPA (in the United States) focus on tributaries that drain into the Niagara River on both sides of the river. Due to differences in sediment criteria between each country, results are compared to the agency’s own relevant criteria. Results from the sediment studies are combined with water quality and biomonitoring, using a weight-of-evidence approach, to prioritize additional track-down efforts.

Lone tree on the point along the Niagara River

Major Accomplishments

The NRTMP met its goal of reducing the ten targeted priority toxics by at least 50%, with reductions exceeding 75% for some substances. More broadly, levels of the plan’s 18 priority toxics declined by as much as 99% between 1986 and 1995. Monitoring through 2019 and 2020 indicates that concentrations of most assessed contaminants continued to decrease over the 33-year monitoring period, although many still exceeded the strictest applicable agency guidelines.

Actions to significantly reduce or eliminate all original point and non-point sources have occurred and continue to be implemented as facilities and sites are identified by the Four Parties.

How does the NRTMP differ from the Remedial Action Plan?

The Niagara River Remedial Action Plan takes a much broader ecosystem approach to improving the Niagara River. However, the NRTMP is a source of important, technical data for the Remedial Action Plan. NRTMP data has been used to assist in assessing the status of Beneficial Use Impairments.

Learn More

Reports related to the work under the NRTMP can be found in our Resource Library, simply type NRTMP in the search bar.

You can also find past reports on the U.S. EPA website here.

Visit Resource Library

The successes of the Niagara River Remedial Action Plan would not have been possible without the cooperation of various levels of government and the active involvement of the public.